STORY UPDATED: check for updates below.
Does a meme that users are sharing contain accurate figures for H1N1 deaths in the United States? No, it does not: The meme posted in March 2020 contains false information and seeks to make an apples-to-oranges comparison between the 2009 H1N1 pandemic, also known as swine flu, and the novel coronavirus, which is currently spreading around the world. Some variations of the meme have more accurate or recent numbers but all variations present the numbers in a higly misleading manner, omitting the fact that the H1N1 cases and deaths are for more than a full year and the coronavirus cases happened in just a few weeks at the start of a curve that is (still) increasing exponentially. H1N1 was also far less lethal to those it infected compared to the current coronavirus (which has a mortality rate more than 100 times higher according to recent estimates). A version shared in September 2020 included updated numbers, but the premise was still false,
The claim appeared in a post published by Sal Cannatella on March 10, 2020 for example. It opened:
US cases: 164
US deaths: 11
Panic Level: Mass hysteria
US Cases: 60.8 million
US Deaths: 22,469
Panic Level: Totally chill
NBC News February 12, 2010: "Swine flu sickened 57 million Americans".
The original post was deleted from Facebook, but this is a screenshot of the meme:
The meme was posted on March 10, 2020. As of that date, the number of U.S. cases of the novel coronavirus had surpassed 1,000, according to The New York Times. The meme downplayed that number, wrongly indicating there were only 164 cases of the virus. It also included a source article from NBC News, but the numbers in the report do not match the figures on the meme.
There are other factual errors on the graphic. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the H1N1 influenza was blamed for the deaths of 12,469 people in the United States. The meme listed 10,000 more.
The meme correctly stated that there were 60.8 million cases of H1N1 reported in the United States. However, only 274,304 people required hospitalization for the virus, according to the CDC.
The author of the meme suggested that there was no panic related to the H1N1 virus and that the mood was "totally chill." This is revisionist history. In August 2009, the Pew Research Center found that 45% of Americans feared that they or a loved one would contract the disease. A CNN article from 2009 contained the headline, "Hysteria over swine flu is the real danger, some say." The report quoted former Rep. Ron Paul of Texas:
There is too much hysteria in the country and so far, there hasn't been that great a danger. It's overblown, grossly so.
The meme sought to compare the total number of H1N1 statistics - data from more than a year - to the cases of novel coronavirus. However, the COVID-19 outbreak has only been reported in the United States since January 21, 2020, with the first confirmed case in Washington state.
According to an article in Business Insider comparing the coronavirus to other outbreaks, the mortality rate is the crucial difference. The report said:
There have been more than 113,000 confirmed cases of the coronavirus, and it has a mortality rate of 3.4%, according to the latest data.
The coronavirus outbreak is more severe than the 2009 outbreak of H1N1, or swine flu. That illness infected between 700 million and 1.4 billion people worldwide but only had a mortality rate of 0.02%.
There are several other versions of the memes being circulated online. Here are a couple:
All of these memes are making a political statement: that the media are somehow unfairly criticizing President Trump's handling of the crisis while leaving Obama unscathed for his response to the H1N1 outbreak.
Even so, the final story on the COVID-19 outbreak is far from being written. It is too soon to compare the current outbreak to the 2009 H1N1 virus. Several memes being shared online seek to do just that, but they contain inaccurate figures, misleading comparisons, and faulty suppositions. Eleven years ago, many Americans were very concerned about the threat of H1N1, as polls showed, so it is false to suggest otherwise.
The more recent version looked like this:
2020-03-15T22:47:42Z 2020-03-15T22:47:42ZAdded additional info to opening paragraph to clarify that even though some variations of these memes have more or less accurate numbers they are still highly misleading because they are comparing numbers from a long period of time with numbers from a very short one and they omit the huge difference in mortality rate.
2020-03-14T16:40:05Z 2020-03-14T16:40:05ZUpdated 9aPT March 14, 2020: Adding meme screenshot to replace deleted post