STORY UPDATED: check for updates below.
Did Bernie Sanders say undocumented immigrants are "entitled" to government benefits during a campaign rally in Texas? No, that's not true: The candidate for the Democratic nomination for president said that his administration will be about "understanding that all of our people, and when I say all I also mean the undocumented in this country -- that all of our people are entitled to basic human rights." Sanders said in previous speeches that he believed health care was a human right and that undocumented immigrants would be included in his "Medicare for All" proposal, but he has not extended it to all government benefits given to U.S. citizens.
The story originated with a YouTube post from the GOP War Room, which featured a clip from Sanders' rally in El Paso on Feb. 20, 2020. It was tweeted by the GOP's rapid response director, Steve Guest, which featured a clip of the rally. It was then picked up within hours by Flag&Cross, which linked together a series of tweets into an article titled "Watch: Bernie Says Undocumented 'Entitled' to Same Government Benefits As U.S. Citizens" (archived here). It begins:
Democrats and entitlement. Everyone deserves everything, even those who have broken the law to get into the United States. No free lunch to Democrats essentially means free everything.
This is the video used by many of these stories. It was posted by the GOP War Room, which is operated by the Republican Party:
What Sanders said was:
Today, we've got 500,000 people sleeping out on the streets of America. Today, we have 18 million people paying 50 percent of their limited income for their housing. Today we have hundreds of bright young people who can not afford to get a higher education. Today, we have 45 million people playing a student debt that many of them cannot afford to pay. So what our campaign is about, and what our administration will about is rethinking America, understanding that all of our people -- and when I say all, I also mean the undocumented in this country -- that all of our people are entitled to basic human rights.
Sander's campaign website does include a 21st Century Economic Bill of Rights which reads:
The 21st Century Economic Bill of Rights establishes that all Americans are entitled to:
The right to a job that pays a living wage
The right to quality health care
The right to a complete education
The right to affordable housing
The right to a clean environment
The right to a secure retirement
While it only references Americans -- not undocumented immigrants -- Sanders has specifically stated in speeches that health care should be provided as a human right to everyone, without regard to immigration status. Sanders has also said that public colleges should be free to everyone in the country. But the claim that Sanders called for the undocumented to the the "same government benefits as U.S. citizens" in this video or elsewhere is unsupported.
Social Security, which includes retirement and disability benefits, is the biggest U.S. government benefits program = costing $1.151 trillion, according to an analysis of President Trump's 2021 budget plan. Undocumented immigrants are not eligible to recieve Social Security benefits, according to this Social Security webpage. Senator Sanders' plan to expand Social Security benefits does not include adding eligibility for undocumented immigrants. Unless he makes such a proposal, it is inaccurate to claim that Sanders wants to give undocumented immigrants "the same government benefits" as U.S. citizens.
Basic human rights, as defined by the United Nations, are "rights inherent to all human beings, regardless of race, sex, nationality, ethnicity, language, religion, or any other status. Human rights include the right to life and liberty, freedom from slavery and torture, freedom of opinion and expression, the right to work and education, and many more."
NewsGuard, a company that uses trained journalists to rank the reliability of websites, describes flagandcross.com as:
A website that covers politics, faith, and entertainment from a conservative, hyper-partisan perspective.
According to NewsGuard, the site can generally be trusted to maintain journalistic standards. Read their full assessment here.
We've written about flagandcross.com previously. Here are our recent articles that mention the site:
- Fake News: Bloomberg Did NOT Say Elderly People Should Be Denied Care Past Certain Age When Ill
- Bernie Sanders At Dem Debate Did NOT Say The Planet Only Has '8 or 9 Years' Before Major Cities Go Underwater
- Fake News: NO Whistleblower Investigating 2018 Broward County Election Fraud Shot Himself Dead
2020-02-27T17:19:03Z 2020-02-27T17:19:03ZUpdated Feb 27, 2020: adding details about Sanders' call for healthcare and college for all, including undocumented immigrants. Also noting the lack of a Sanders call for including undocumented immigrants in Social Security retirement, disability, benefits.
2020-02-24T08:16:57Z 2020-02-24T08:16:57ZCorrection: changed "they" to "that many of them" in transcript of Sanders speech.