Fact Check: 'Comments Made In The Year 1957' List Has A History, But Not Back To The '50s

Fact Check

  • by: Sarah Thompson
Fact Check: 'Comments Made In The Year 1957' List Has A History, But Not Back To The '50s Nostalgic Lore

Does this collection of comments date back to 1955 or 1957? No, that's not true: These 20 quips do harken to an earlier time but they do not trace all the way back to the 1950s. This contrived collection of comments seems to have been a popular email to forward as early as 2001. It has since been repurposed in other formats. The similar structure of many of the statements points to a single author who was working with the benefit of hindsight to construct uncanny "predictions" from the '50s, wrapped with nostalgia for the past.

The comments resurfaced as an image of a newspaper clipping in a post (archived here) published on Facebook on December 12, 2020. Under the title, "Comments made in the year 1957," it reads:

  • "I'll tell you one thing, if things keep going the way they are, it's going to be impossible to buy a week's groceries for $20."
  • "I'm afraid to send my kids to the movies any more. Ever since they let Clark Gable get by with saying 'damn' in "Gone With The Wind," it seems every new movie has either 'hell' or 'damn' in it."
  • "Have you seen the new cars coming out next year? It won't be long before $5000 will only buy a used one."
  • "If cigarettes keep going up in price, I'm going to quit. A quarter a pack is ridiculous."
  • "Did you hear the post office is thinking about charging a dime just to mail a letter?"
  • "If they raise the minimum wage to $1, nobody will be able to hire outside help at the store."
  • "When I first started driving, who would have thought gas would someday cost 29 cents a gallon. Guess we'd be better off leaving the car in the garage."
  • "Kids today are impossible. Those duck tail haircuts make it impossible to stay groomed. Next thing you know, boys will be wearing their hair as long as the girls."
  • "If they think I'll pay 50 cents for a hair cut, forget it."
  • "I read the other day where some scientist thinks it's possible to put a man on the moon by the end of the of the century. They even have some fellows they call astronauts preparing for it down in Texas."
  • "Did you see where some baseball player just signed a contract for $75,000 a year just to play ball? It wouldn't surprise me if someday they'll be making more than the president."
  • "I never thought I'd see the day all our kitchen appliances would be electric. They are even making electric typewriters now."
  • "It's too bad things are so tough nowadays. I see where a few married women are having to work to make ends meet."
  • "It won't be long before young couples are going to have to hire someone to watch their kids so they can both work."
  • "Marriage doesn't mean a thing any more; those Hollywood stars seem to be getting divorced at the drop of a hat."
  • "I'm just afraid the Volkswagen car is going to open the door to a whole lot of foreign business."
  • "Thank goodness I won't live to see the day when the Government takes half our income in taxes. I sometimes wonder if we are electing the best people to congress."
  • "The drive-in restaurant is convenient in nice weather, but I seriously doubt they will ever catch on."
  • "There is no sense going to Lincoln or Omaha anymore for a weekend. It costs nearly $15 a night to stay in a hotel."
  • "No one can afford to be sick any more; $35 a day in the hospital is too rich for my blood."

This is what the post looked like on Facebook at the time of writing:

Facebook screenshot

(Source: Facebook screenshot taken on Tue Dec 15 16:47:43 2020 UTC)

The earliest instance of this trope Lead Stories uncovered was posted to a forum board at TurboDodge.com on December 31, 2001. Another copy is found in a small-town online newspaper called the WaynedaleNews.com that was published on February 20, 2002 . An undated edition of the list of 1957 quotes was found on ClevelandSeniors.com, a website that is still up and running, and archived on September 22, 2002.

Some time along the way the year rolled back to 1955.

On January 8, 2006, Snopes published an article, "Are These Comments from 1955? Lists of entries that attempt to illustrate 'the way things used to be' for modern readers can serve a variety of purposes." The article delves into several of the claims of the quotes. The claims addressed in the Snopes article are nearly identical to the newspaper clipping meme, except the date is 1955 instead of 1957, and two small details: the eventual price of the used car is estimated to be $2,000 rather than $5,000; and the astronauts, rather than preparing for space flight down in Texas, are in Florida instead.

I read the other day where some scientists think it's possible to put a man on the moon by the end of the century. They even have some fellows they call astronauts preparing for it down in Florida."

This detail about the space flight, in either the 1955 or 1957 version of this meme, is a clear indication that the quote did not originate in these years. It wasn't until December of 1958 that the word astronaut was agreed upon, and the plans for the recruitment process that would begin in 1959 were drafted. The story is described in an essay by Allen O. Gamble, Ph.D. who was there when it happened. He was the associate director of personnel for manpower of the newly formed National Aeronautics and Space Administration, NASA:

Oddly enough, one of the first hot issues was the names or terms. What should we call the men who would one day fly into space? At Langley Research Center on December 1,1958, we brainstormed, and every name mentioned went up on the blackboard. Of course, somebody said "spaceman" and someone else said "superman" and still another said "space pilot." But perhaps he would be a passenger instead of a pilot, so some wise guy proposed "man-in-a-can." Other suggestions were made, some kidding and some serious. Then one of us came up with a solid suggestion, "Mercury," which made sense. It referred not to the planet Mercury and not to the quicksilver metal mercury, but to the messenger of the Roman gods, who had wings on his heels and legendary speed of flight.

But someone had heard the word mentioned before, so he called Washington. Sure enough, only five days earlier, on November 26, NASA headquarters had officially adopted Project Mercury as the name of the first American manned spaceflight effort, but not yet used the term publicly or even told us. With our best name so far already taken, out came the dictionaries and thesauruses. Someone found that the term 'aeronaut,' referring to those who ride in balloons and other lighter than-air vehicles, was derived from "sailor in the air." From this we arrived at 'astronaut,' meaning "sailor among the stars." We thought we had actually invented a new word, but it later turned up as having been used earlier, in 1929, probably in science fiction. In any event, the term astronaut rang true and was adopted.

In 2009 iFunny.com published, "18 Funny Comments Made in the Year 1955." In this edition the used car is priced at $1,000, the cigarettes are 20 cents a pack, the letter costs seven cents to mail and the hotel is $2.00 a night. A 33-frame slideshow was published to Slideserve.com on August 14, 2014, "Remembering 1955." This includes some additional 1950s trivia about slang, cars, entertainment and music, and ends with 10 quips from this meme using the same numbers as published on iFunny. The haircut is 30 cents, the hospital stay is $15, the ball player is paid $50,000, gas is 25 cents a gallon, and the groceries for a week are $10.

There is even a 26-page book published by Sebastian Shug, in May 8, 2020, "Comments Made in the year 1957," dedicated, "For the boomers," and crediting the content aggregator iFunny for the quotes.

A valuable insight into the economy of the mid 1950s, as the United States recovered from World War II and then the Korean War, is this 1959 publication from the United States Department of Labor, "Consumer Prices in the United States 1953-58 Price Trends and Indexes." Although the actual prices of items are not always listed in a consumer price index, compared to the decade earlier, the rate of inflation had slowed tremendously.

PriceIndex.JPGSource: Bulletin No. 1256 United States Department of Labor 1959

Want to inform others about the accuracy of this story?

See who is sharing it (it might even be your friends...) and leave the link in the comments.:

  Sarah Thompson

Sarah Thompson lives with her family and pets on a small farm in Indiana. She founded a Facebook page and a blog called “Exploiting the Niche” in 2017 to help others learn about manipulative tactics and avoid scams on social media. Since then she has collaborated with journalists in the USA, Canada and Australia and since December 2019 she works as a Social Media Authenticity Analyst at Lead Stories.


Read more about or contact Sarah Thompson

About Us

International Fact-Checking Organization Meta Third-Party Fact Checker

Lead Stories is a fact checking website that is always looking for the latest false, misleading, deceptive or inaccurate stories, videos or images going viral on the internet.
Spotted something? Let us know!.

Lead Stories is a:


Subscribe to our newsletter

* indicates required

Please select all the ways you would like to hear from Lead Stories LLC:

You can unsubscribe at any time by clicking the link in the footer of our emails. For information about our privacy practices, please visit our website.

We use Mailchimp as our marketing platform. By clicking below to subscribe, you acknowledge that your information will be transferred to Mailchimp for processing. Learn more about Mailchimp's privacy practices here.

Most Read

Most Recent

Share your opinion